TheMarvel Cinematic Universecame close to casting different actors for some very important roles, and that could have completely altered the trajectory of the shared universe. If there isone thing that Marvel is known to pretty much always get right, it is casting. Even when some projects rank among theMCU’s worst moviesor shows, there is commonly a saving grace in the form of an actor or a few who turn in amazing performances.
On the other end of the spectrum, some MCU movies have become so popular because their potential was brought up by talented performers. That should continue for theupcoming projects on Marvel Studios' slate, ascasting director Sarah Halley Finn has been part of the franchise from the startand shows no signs of going away anytime soon. While Marvel has a long list of success stories, the studio did come close to casting different actors for key roles, and some of them would have completely changed the MCU.
10Emily Blunt As Black Widow
Played By Scarlett Johansson In The MCU
Emily Blunt is a name that has been part of the MCU’s rumor mill for quite some time. More recently, she wassaid to be one of the choices to play Sue Storm inThe Fantastic Four: First Steps. However, she never showed interest in the role, which was more due to how her husband, John Krasinski, played a Reed Richards variant in the MCU.
That said, Blunt did come close to joining the franchise in the past. The actresswas offered the Black Widow role for 2010’sIron Man, which she wanted to take, but Blunt had to turn it down due to contractual obligations. Her contract with Fox meant she had to star in another movie from the studio,Gulliver’s Travels, which made it impossible for her to be Natasha Romanoff. On theHappy Sad Confusedpodcast in 2023, Blunt praised Scarlett Johansson, saying, “The best girl got it.”
9John Krasinski As Captain America
Played By Chris Evans In The MCU
Blunt’s husband, John Krasinski, also came very close to one of the MCU’s biggest roles. After Marvel Studios approached Chris Evans to play Steve Rogers, and the actor initially turned down the offer, other actors were looked at for the part. Krasinski was one of the stars who made it really far into the process, evengetting to screen test in the Captain America suit.
10 Best Steve Rogers & Sam Wilson Captain America Fight Scenes In The MCU, Ranked
Captain America: Brave New World added many exciting fight scenes to the MCU, and Steve Rogers & Sam Wilson have had major fights as Captain America.
One of the funniest tidbits from that audition process was when Krasinski told the story onThe Ellen DeGeneres Showof how Thor actor Chris Hemsworth walked byThe Officestar as he was putting on the Captain America suit and said, “You look good, mate,” and Krasinski immediately felt inadequate, comparing himself to Hemsworth. While the role ultimately went to Evans,Krasinski at least joined the MCU as a Reed RichardsvariantinDoctor Strange in the Multiverse of Madnessafter years of fans campaigning for him to get the role.
8Tom Cruise As Iron Man
Played By Robert Downey Jr. In The MCU
Tom Cruise is one of Hollywood’s all-time greatest stars. As such, having him join a superhero franchise would be huge. That almost happened right from the start of the MCU, as Cruise’s near-miss with Iron Man has become one of the most famous stories related to “what could have been” in the superhero genre. Before Robert Downey Jr. was cast as Tony Stark, Cruise was approached for the role.
2012
2015
2018
2019
2026
Avengers: Secret Wars
2027
In theMCU: The Reign of Marvel Studiosbook (viaCBR), Marvel’s president, Kevin Feige, explained why Cruise’s casting as Iron Man fell through. According to Feige, the reason was financial.Cruise simply asked for too high a fee for an untested superhero property like Iron Manat the time. Downey went on to become the MCU’s biggest star. Cruise has been rumored to appear as an Iron Man variant in the MCU’s Multiverse Saga, which has yet to happen.
7Tom Hiddleston As Thor
Played By Chris Hemsworth In The MCU
Tom Hiddleston is the first case on the list of an actor who did not get the role they auditioned for, butended up playing another major role instead in the MCU. Hiddleston was brought in by director Kenneth Branagh for the first Thor movie, and the actor even donned a blonde wig to try and nab the top role. Hiddleston’s Thor audition was released onThe Tonight with Jimmy Fallon Show.
While Chris Hemsworth was notably the best fit for Thor, Hiddleston’s audition showed Marvel Studios that the actor had the kind of talent the studio could use for another role. He was then cast as Thor’s brother, Loki, becoming the villain of the first Avengers movie and thus essential to the success of the franchise.Hiddleston now boasts two seasons of Disney+‘sLoki, showing how popular his character has become.
6Joaquin Phoenix As Doctor Strange
Played By Benedict Cumberbatch In The MCU
Doctor Strangedirector Scott Derrickson always wanted Benedict Cumberbatch to lead the movie. However, there were scheduling conflicts, and the actor was not available for the initial period the MCU movie would be shot. Due to that, Derrickson looked at other names, with Joaquin Phoenix being the one the director spent the most time with. Ultimately, he toldSlashFilmthat, with time, it became clear Phoenix just did not belong in the film and the MCU.
Disney then moved the film’s release date from summer to fall so that Cumberbatch could play Doctor Strange. Speaking about the ordeal toEntertainment Weekly, Phoenix explained his side of things. According to the actor, “It never felt like [superhero movies would] really be fulfilling.” In the end,he joined a very grounded DC franchise, starring in two Joker movies. The first was the highest-grossing R-rated movie of all time for years, while the sequel was received negatively.
5Wilson Bethel As Captain America
Wilson Bethel makes for another case on the list of an actor who did not get the role they auditioned for but ended up as another important character in the franchise. Bethel was one of the actors who were up for the Steve Rogers role when Chris Evans was still unsure about playing Captain America. AtFAN EXPO San Francisco 2024,Bethel opened up about losing the role.
According to the MCU actor, he “went through multiple rounds of screen testing,” saying that the Captain America suit felt incredible. However, despite seeing that things were apparently going his way, he was heartbroken when his agent called to tell him Evans got the part. After that,Bethel would be cast as Benjamin Poindexter, aka Bullseye, in Daredevil season 3. Years later, Bethel now returns as Bullseye under Marvel Studios, appearing in Daredevil: Born Again season 1.
4Matthew McConaughey As The Hulk
Played By Edward Norton/Mark Ruffalo In The MCU
Matthew McConaughey is one of the most well-known actors in Hollywood. The star has amassed awards and exciting projects throughout his career, which one would think would make him an easy yes for a superhero role. However, it turns out that Marvel does not think like that. On theHappy Sad Confusedpodcast in 2020,McConaughey revealed that he threw his hat in the ring to play the Hulk, but Marvel passed.
When he approached Marvel for the role, the answer was, “No, thank you.”
McConaughey is a major fan of Lou Ferrigno’sThe Incredible Hulkseries, which is why he had a desire to play the conflicted hero. However, when he approached Marvel for the role, the answer was, “No, thank you.” 2008’sThe Incredible Hulkmovie starred Edward Norton, with the role being recast for 2012’sThe Avengers.Since then, Mark Ruffalo has given life to Bruce Banner in the MCU.
3Chadwick Boseman As Drax
Played By Dave Bautista In The MCU
Chadwick Boseman is one of the MCU’s most popular stars. Before his untimely death, the actor played T’Challa, the MCU’s first Black Panther, in a solo movie, two Avengers entries, and more.2018’sBlack Pantherwas a cultural phenomenon, becoming a major box office hit and even being nominated for Best Picture at the Oscars. Boseman’s performance played a huge role in that, but things could have been very different.
In an excerpt from theMCU: The Reign of Marvel Studiosbook shared byVanity Fair, it is revealed thatBoseman first auditioned for the role of Drax the Destroyerin the MCU for James Gunn’sGuardians of the Galaxy. Dave Bautista made the lovable brute one of the franchise’s funniest characters. Boseman’s dramatic skills were better suited for Black Panther, and his version of Drax would likely have been very different from the one the MCU ended up with.
2Liam Hemsworth As Thor
One of the MCU’s most interesting behind-the-scenes facts is that a different Hemsworth brother was almost Thor. Speaking withW Magazinein 2017, MCU Thor actor Chris Hemsworth revealed that his brother,The Hunger Gamesfranchise star Liam Hemsworth, nearly got the coveted Marvel role before him. According to the MCU star, Liam ended up getting a few callbacks for the role andended up as one of the four or five final candidates.
Liam Hemsworth has replaced Henry Cavill as Geralt of Rivia on Netflix’s The Witcher.
Hemsworth had gone months without hearing any news while his brother was moving forward in the Thor casting process. Ultimately,Liam was deemed too young for the role, which led to the brothers’ agent suggesting Hemsworth be brought back in. From there, things started to work out, with Hemsworth playing Thor to this day in the MCU.Thor 5is rumored to be in development.
1Zooey Deschanel As The Wasp
Played By Evangeline Lilly In The MCU
Finally, the last entry on the list is related to the MCU’s first Avengers movie. Director Joss Whedon was thinking of using the Wasp in the film due to scheduling conflicts with Scarlett Johansson, sothe Wasp would have replaced Black Widow in 2012’sThe Avengers. As revealed inThe Story of Marvel Studios: The Making of the Marvel Cinematic Universebook,Whedon wanted to cast Zooey Deschanel as the Wasp.
The Avengersproducer Jeremy Latcham revealed that"The Wasp was the funniest character in the whole movie.“Deschanel’s casting as Hope van Dyne would have completely changed MCU history. The Wasp — and Ant-Man — would only join the franchise years later, in 2015’sAnt-Man, with Evangeline Lilly playing the character. If The Wasp had been part of the MCU’s original Avengers, the character’s popularity and overall role in the franchise would likely have been much bigger, fundamentally changing theMCU.
Marvel Cinematic Universe
The Marvel Cinematic Universe is a multimedia superhero franchise that began in 2008 with Paramount’s Iron Man starring Robert Downey Jr. The franchise quickly grew in popularity, with Disney eventually buying out Marvel Entertainment in 2009. The MCU consists of dozens of movies and TV shows, most notably Avengers: Endgame, WandaVision, and Loki.
