Tobey Maguire’s acting is so much more than just a certain wall-crawling superhero. Maguire has been acting professionally since 1989, with his career really taking off in the late ’90s. After a string of acclaimed supporting roles, Maguire broke out with 1998’sPleasantville, and won viewers' hearts with his distinctly dorky, often quiet presence on screen. However, what really launched Maguire to the top of the A-list was playing Peter Parker in Sam Raimi’sSpider-Manmovies, a role he reprised in the MCU’sSpider-Man: No Way Home(2021).
With his decades-spanning career,Maguire has acted in everything from comedies likeTropic Thunderto period pieces likeSeabiscuitand has receivedcritical acclaim for his acting.There is something indescribable about how Maguire uses his eyes onscreen, always providing viewers with a window into how his character is feeling. However, his career is not without its ebbs and flows, which is typical for many actors.Maguire has become memesand has also been nominated for a Golden Globe. But, no matter what Maguire stars in, he often gives a memorable performance.
Tropic Thunder
Cast
Written and directed by Ben Stiller, Tropic Thunder follows a group of bumbling actors attempting to make a Vietnam War film, who find themselves dropped into a real-life warzone when they are abandoned in the middle of the jungle they are shooting the film in. Stiller also stars in the film, with an ensemble cast that includes Jack Black, Robert Downey Jr., and Jay Baruchel.
Tobey Maguire only has a cameo inTropic Thunder,but is absolutely hilarious, andgets some of the film’s biggest laughs with his brief performance. In the trailer for a fictional film calledSatan’s Alley, Maguire plays opposite Robert Downey Jr. in what appears to be an illicit romance between two priests. Sadly, the audience doesn’t see much of Maguire and Downey Jr. on screen.
But Maguire whispering at the end of the trailer, “I’ve been a bad, bad, boy Father” lets the audience know exactly what kind of filmSatan’s Alley would be, without even seeing it, and that’s the beauty of the fake trailers perfectly crafted for this film. Although Maguire’s part inTropic Thunderis small, he proves that there are no small parts, just small actors. His performancewas so beloved thateven Kate Winslet complimented Maguire on hisTropic Thunderrole.
Spider-Man: No Way Home
For the first time in the cinematic history of Spider-Man, our friendly neighborhood hero is unmasked and no longer able to separate his normal life from the trials and tribulations of being a superhero. In Spider-Man: No Way Home, Peter Parker (Tom Holland) asks for help from Doctor Strange (Benedict Cumberbatch) when his identity becomes a problem for the ones he loves. Unfortunately, when the spell goes wrong, Spider-Man will now have to face off with villains such as Doctor Octopus (Alfred Molina) and Electro (Jamie Foxx) as Peter finally comes to terms that he can’t run from being Spider-Man. Supported by his close friends and help from an unexpected place (or multiverse), Spider-Man will go toe-to-toe with some of the most legendary foes in his storied history.
The MCU’sSpider-Man: No Way Homeonly sees Tobey Maguire in a cameo, but like withTropic Thunder, it’s one where he steals the show. He is featured alongside the two other versions of Spider-Man seen in the universe, played by Tom Holland and Andrew Garfield. Maguire’s presence in the film is a reminder to Marvel fans that the cinematic universe stretches back to a simpler time when superhero films weren’t commonplace in the cinema landscape.
The MCU’s New Spider-Man Can Finally Let Tom Holland’s Peter Parker Grow
Marvel Studios will debut a new version of Spider-Man in 2025, and the hero can finally lead to a whole new chapter for Tom Holland’s Peter Parker.
Maguire manages to stand out among the other two versions of the hero, with his Spider-Man taking on a new role inNo Way Home. He almost serves as a father figure to the other two Spideys in the film. Maguire’s presence is soft; he even tries to hype up Andrew Garfield’s Peter Parker and helps him steer away from negative self-talk. The film is full of nostalgia, withMaguire’s version of Spider-Manproviding a callback to Spider-Man fans of all ages.
The Ice Storm
The Ice Storm is set during Thanksgiving weekend in 1973, following the Hood family as they face personal and societal upheavals. A significant ice storm—the most severe in a century—serves as the backdrop, further complicating their relationships and magnifying underlying tensions within the family.
Based on the novel by Rick Moody,The Ice Stormserved as the launching pad for Maguire’s career. Directed byprolific filmmaker Ang Lee, Maguire plays Paul in an ensemble cast featuring Sigourney Weaver and Kevin Kline. The story follows two upper-middle-class families as they fall deeper into dysfunction around the Thanksgiving holiday. While many remember the “key party” storyline inThe Ice Storm, the film is so much more, and provides a searing commentary on existentialism and suburban sexuality.
For his first major performance, Maguire does an excellent job portraying a lovesick teenager.
For his first major performance, Maguire does an excellent job portraying a lovesick teenager, as Paul has found himself head over heels for Libbets (Katie Holmes). But another man is in love with her, leaving Paul in the middle of a love triangle.Maguire uses the tension present in Paul’s situation to create a nuanced performance.At the end of the film, the audience can tell, just by the look on Maguire’s face, that he is heartbroken and that some illusion he believed about his family has been shattered. Again, Maguire makes Paul’s turmoil clear through his emotions and performance.
Pawn Sacrifice
Pawn Sacrifice is a biographical drama directed by Edward Zwick, centered on the life of American chess prodigy Bobby Fischer, portrayed by Tobey Maguire. The film depicts Fischer’s intense rivalry with Soviet chess champion Boris Spassky, played by Liev Schreiber, during the Cold War era. Exploring Fischer’s genius and his mental struggles, the narrative captures the high-stakes world of international chess and the psychological pressures faced by its players.
Pawn Sacrificedelved into the complexities of professional chess beforeThe Queen’s Gambit. The film centers around a young Bobby Fischer, played by Tobey Maguire, as he tries to beat Soviet chess grandmasters during the Cold War. Fischer soon finds himself at thecenter of a propaganda campaignpushing American superiority over Soviet rule.
The match between Maguire’s Fischer and Liev Schiber’s Boris Spassy is one of the film’s highlights, thanks to Maguire’s commitment to the role.
At its core,Pawn Sacrificecapitalizes on the intensity of chess and offers many high-impact scenes.Maguire shines as Bobby Fischer and matches the invigorating tone of the film.The actor does an excellent job showing the chess master’s descent into paranoia. His expressions are over the top and indicative of someone who is having a mental breakdown. The match between Maguire’s Fischer and Liev Schiber’s Boris Spassy is one of the film’s highlights, thanks to Maguire’s commitment to the role.
The Great Gatsby
The Great Gatsby is a 2013 drama romance film based on the book of the same name by F. Scott Fitzgerald. The movie is one of many adaptations of the iconic 1925 novel, this time starring Leonardo DiCaprio as Jay Gatsby and Tobey Maguire as Nick Carraway. The film received a polarizing reception upon release but won two Oscars at the 2014 Academy Awards.
AlthoughThe Great Gatsbyis better remembered for Leonardo DiCaprio’s champagne-toasting depiction of the title character, Maguire gives an exceptional performance. He plays Gatsby’s curious neighbor Nick, who is just as interested in Gatsby’s extravagant life as the audience. The film is a bit decisive, holding only a 48% on Rotten Tomatoes and being met with mixed reviews. However,The Great Gatsbyis also remembered for its breathtaking depiction of the roaring 1920s, and won two Oscars — for Best Costume and Best Production Design.
All 8 F. Scott Fitzgerald Movie Adaptations, Ranked
While numerous film adaptations of F. Scott Fitzgerald’s works exist, not all manage to capture the brilliance of the original written pieces.
However, Maguire is the film’s every man, meant to contrast Gatsby’s larger-than-life persona, and the actor does well at crafting a likable character that audiences can latch on to. Also, his underacting in the role perfectly juxtaposes the stunning visuals and grand scenes typical of a Baz Luhrmann picture.Even if Maguire isn’t the star in this film, he still manages to shine as bright as the tinsel on Gatsby’s dance floor.
Maguire Plays Red Pollard
Seabiscuit
Seabiscuit, directed by Gary Ross, chronicles the true story of an undersized Depression-era racehorse whose unexpected success lifted the spirits of the team behind it and the nation. The film highlights Seabiscuit’s journey from an underdog to a symbol of hope during challenging times.
Seabiscuitis a seven-time Oscar-nominated film where Maguire plays a jockey who rides the titular horse. It’s full ofheart and great performancesfrom Maguire, Jeff Bridges, and Chris Cooper. Taking place during The Great Depression, the film never skips on emotional scenes. Maguire gives an emotionally nuanced performance as Red Pollard to boot.
The film’s ending is a tear-jerker that re-enforces its message about beating the odds.
The bond between Maguire and Seabiscuit is what makes the film an emotional experience. The actor’s delicacy and care in handling the horse make it clear thatMaguire is both a capable actor and that his character has agenuine connection with the racehorse.The film’s ending is a tear-jerker that re-enforces its message about beating the odds. ThoughSeabiscuitwas nominated for the coveted Best Picture prize at the 2004 Academy Awards, it lost toThe Lord of the Rings: Return of the King.
Brothers
Brothers is a 2009 drama film directed by Jim Sheridan. It stars Tobey Maguire as Sam Cahill, a soldier presumed dead, and Jake Gyllenhaal as his brother Tommy. Natalie Portman plays Grace, Sam’s wife, who finds comfort in Tommy during Sam’s absence. Upon Sam’s unexpected return, the family dynamics take a turn as they navigate the complexities of his traumatic experiences and the altered relationships within the family.
Maguire’s performance inBrothersis one of his most critically acclaimed, and theactor received a Golden Globe nominationfor his portrayal of Sam Cahill, a Marine suffering from extreme PTSD. Maguire’s nomination is well-deserved as every moment he’s on-screen, the audience believes his character is in pain. Even though his PTSD isn’t apparent until later in the film, Maguire conveys his suffering through his quiet, detached nature and soulful eyes.
The film also delves into veterans' mental health and theperils that soldiers are left with for years after serving. On top of that,Maguire’s performance beautifully complements Jake Gyllenhaal, who plays Tommy, Sam’s drifter brother, who falls in love with Sam’s wife, Grace (Natalie Portman), after Sam is presumed dead. The two work off each other and channel their tension through their intense interactions.Brothersis an emotional experience driven by Maguire’s grounded performance.
The Cider House Rules
The Cider House Rules, directed by Lasse Hallström, is a drama based on John Irving’s novel. The film stars Tobey Maguire as Homer Wells, an orphan trained in medicine by Dr. Wilbur Larch, portrayed by Michael Caine. The story follows Homer as he leaves the orphanage to explore the world, grappling with complex moral issues. Charlize Theron also stars as Candy Kendall, a key figure Homer encounters on his journey.
Maguire plays the lead in the Oscar-nominated filmThe Cider House Rules. The film is notable for its depiction of abortion, and it is compelling to see how Maguire’s character, Homer, changes his views on the issue. Homer is a bright orphan who is taught how to perform the procedure by his mentor, Dr. Wilbur Larch (Michael Caine). Maguire represents Homer’s turmoil perfectly through both tender scenes of reflection and over-the-top scenes showing how torn up he is.
Michael Caine won the Oscar for Best Supporting Actor, andThe Cider House Rulesalso picked up the Best Adapted Screenplay statuette, won by John Irving, who wrote the source material.
Homer’s eventual change of heart is perfectly underscored by thebleak world presented in the film.The orphanage Homer grew up in and the apple cider farm he winds up at are both portrayed as uninviting and scary, perfectly encapsulating the intense themes in the film.
The setting never overshadows the hero’s journey.
But the setting never overshadows the hero’s journey. Homer remains at the center of the story because he must change his view on abortion when he is confronted with a forced pregnancy. Beyond abortion,The Cider House Rulesoffers commentary on not adoption and migrant workers that will leave viewers pondering these issues long after the credits role.
Pleasantville
Pleasantville is a drama that explores themes of change and self-discovery, as two modern teenagers find themselves transported into a 1950s television show. The movie delves into social issues and individual freedoms, highlighting the contrast between the idealized past and the complexities of the real world. With its unique premise, Pleasantville offers a thought-provoking narrative on the impact of transformation on a seemingly perfect society.
Beyond its cast of young A-list talent,Pleasantvilleis well remembered for its ingenious premise. Maguire plays the sweet and nerdy teenage David, who finds himself trapped in a 1950s television show with his much cooler tin sister, Jennifer, played by Reese Witherspoon. The fictional town of Pleasantville begins to turn to color as the characters influence the residents, and the film’s combination of black and white and color creates a unique viewing experience.
Maguire’s earnest performance as David also adds toPleasantville’s whimsy, making an impression on not only the fictional town but also the audience. By the end of the film, both David and the viewers learn that utopia doesn’t exist, and that he alone is responsible for creating the life he wants.Pleasantvilleis a striking film because of its unforgettable visuals and subversive themes.
Spider-Man
Spider-Man is the first film in Sam Raimi’s trilogy starring Tobey Maguire as Peter Parker. Released in 2002, the film introduced superhero fans to a live-action Norman Osborn, played by Willem Dafoe, who is transformed into his villainous alter ego, Green Goblin, after being forced out of Oscorp Industries. At the same time, Peter Parker is grappling with his newfound abilities as the iconic wall-crawler.
Maguire’s most iconic rolegives way to his best film series. If he’s remembered for anything, it will be for his depiction of Spider-Man in the original trilogy,directed by Sam Raimi. There’s even talk of Maguire wearing the spandexSpidey suit again in a potentialSpider-Man 4. Maguire’s Peter Parker is a nerd who fails in many social situations. But once he becomes Spider-Man, he steps into his confidence and is even able to save New York from afleet of the most memorable Spider-Man villains.
Maguire pioneered the cinematic Spider-Man audiences know today.
Maguire pioneered the cinematic Spider-Man audiences know today. His Peter Parker is the ultimate representation of a nobody becoming a superhero in a story that almost feels Cinderalla-inspired. Maguire’s Peter Parker who eventually wins the heart of not only Mary Jane but also the hearts of audience members. After all, with great power comes great responsibility, and Maguire, arguably, is responsible for making Spider-Man the beloved hero he is today.
